The circuit actually sounds pretty cool with a guitar. It would probably help to put an LPF before the amplifier stage if you're after a pure square wave. Since it's a comparator, the signal cuts out completely after it gets below a certain level which gives it a gated fuzz sound.
Comparator Fuzz
I started this experiment with the goal of creating a square wave out of a guitar signal using a comparator. The idea was to send the signal through a comparator using signal ground as the reference voltage. I drew the expected result in my notebook and then realized that I could also vary the duty cycle of the square wave by varying the reference voltage with a potentiometer.
The circuit actually sounds pretty cool with a guitar. It would probably help to put an LPF before the amplifier stage if you're after a pure square wave. Since it's a comparator, the signal cuts out completely after it gets below a certain level which gives it a gated fuzz sound.